So was there a Chola naval base on the Nicobar Islands, or not?

TL;DR: No. There is no credible evidence of this, and yet the internet keeps confidently claiming there was.

Wikipedia says there was. Repeatedly. Let’s chase every citation down and see what is going on here.

(Source Map of the Chola Empire at around its peak. Note the blue dot on the Nicobar Islands. I don’t doubt by the way, that the Chola exerted some form of control over Nicobar, perhaps even landing there or harvesting resources from there, or perhaps even doing something there. Though none that has really been established. But anyway this article is about examining the most expansive possible version of this claim, that they actually had a naval base on the island)

Article 1: “History of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands”

This article states:

Rajendra I, used the Andaman and Nicobar Islands as a strategic naval base to launch an expedition against the Sriwijaya Empire (Indonesia). The Cholas called the island Ma-Nakkavaram (“great open/naked land”), found in the Thanjavur inscription of 1050 AD. European traveller Marco Polo (12th–13th century) also referred to this island as ‘Necuverann’ and a corrupted form of the Tamil name Nakkavaram would have led to the modern name Nicobar during the British colonial period.”

But I’m pretty sure it is essentially a fabrication.

(Source Inscriptions at the Brihadisvara Temple. Inscriptions like these are one of the main actual real sources briefly mentioning Nicobar, which get laundered into the naval base claim)

Continue reading

Linguistic Clues towards Madagascar’s Population History

This is the kind of post which needs to start with some maps and then contain even more maps:

Notice Madagascar in the lower left hand corner. (source)

This map is useful because it shows that Malagasy (the primary language of Madagascar) is in the same sub-group as Bornean languages. There is a little pocket of this sub-group on Sumatra, but otherwise they seem oddly distant, with Sumatra and Java in between. The distance between the Indonesian archipelago and Madagascar is vast  (4,700 mi or 7,500 km as the crow flies, if we start from Borneo), but this map doesn’t really represent that. See this other map:

A lot of people (who are vaguely nerdy and interested in languages) know that Madagascar was settled by Austronesians from what is now Indonesia. This was certainly an impressive feat, and one which seems pretty challenging to do, even for the skilled seafarers of the ancient Pacific. But a third map, with a bit of a different perspective makes it a little more comprehensible:

Continue reading